Fusion HCR is Hiring!
Role: Payroll Audit Supervisor
Location: Birmingham, AL
Work Arrangement: Onsite
Employment Type: Full-time
Industry: Insurance
This opportunity is with an insurance organization serving businesses in transportation and related industries. The Payroll Audit Supervisor will help oversee workers’ compensation audit operations, support an established audit team, and uphold accurate, timely, and consistent work. The role combines hands-on audit review with team coordination, quality oversight, and process improvement.
Position Overview
Fusion HCR is seeking a Payroll Audit Supervisor to coordinate workers’ compensation payroll audit operations and support the professionals responsible for completing them. This hands-on role oversees audit workflows, reviews completed audits for accuracy and compliance, and helps ensure assignments meet quality and turnaround expectations.
The supervisor will coach team members, coordinate work among internal staff and external auditors, and work with department leadership to monitor performance and address service gaps. The position also involves partnering with teams across the organization, supporting relationships with policyholders and brokers, and improving audit processes and systems. The successful candidate will contribute to current operations while having the opportunity to progress toward broader management responsibilities based on performance, business needs, and readiness.
Key Responsibilities
-
Coordinate daily audit workflows and assign year-end and cancellation audits to internal staff, independent auditors, and external service providers.
-
Monitor workloads, turnaround times, productivity measures, and quality standards; work with department leadership to identify service gaps and address performance issues.
-
Coach, train, and provide feedback to audit support staff to strengthen proficiency and team performance.
-
Conduct and oversee workers’ compensation payroll audits, reviewing documentation, classifications, and results for accuracy and compliance with applicable guidelines.
-
Research audit and classification guidance through NCCI and other recognized industry resources.
-
Coordinate with auditors and vendors to resolve discrepancies, address quality concerns, and support timely completion.
-
Communicate with policyholders, brokers, and other stakeholders about audit findings, questions, and disputes.
-
Partner with underwriting, business development, marketing, IT, and risk management; identify workflow improvements and support audit system changes.
Required Qualifications
-
Professional experience conducting workers’ compensation payroll audits.
-
Strong knowledge of payroll practices, workers’ compensation class codes, audit procedures, and applicable industry rules and guidelines.
-
Ability to research, interpret, and apply guidance from NCCI and other relevant industry resources.
-
Experience reviewing audit documentation, validating payroll information, and identifying discrepancies.
-
Familiarity with payroll audit software and related systems.
-
Proficiency in Microsoft Excel, Word, and Outlook, including reviewing and analyzing payroll data.
-
Strong written and verbal communication skills, with the ability to explain audit findings clearly and professionally.
-
Effective problem-solving, negotiation, and conflict-resolution skills for addressing questions or disagreements about audit results.
-
Strong organization and time-management skills, with the ability to manage multiple assignments and time-sensitive deadlines.
-
Ability to coordinate work, monitor quality and deadlines, and adapt to changing priorities.
-
A college degree is not required in place of relevant workers’ compensation payroll audit experience.
Why Join Us
-
Contribute to an established workers’ compensation audit operation and support accurate, consistent outcomes.
-
Combine hands-on audit work with team coaching, workflow coordination, and process improvement.
-
Collaborate with audit leadership and partners across underwriting, business development, marketing, IT, and risk management.
-
Build experience coordinating internal staff, independent auditors, and external service providers.
-
Help improve audit workflows and systems as business needs and workloads evolve.
-
Pursue the opportunity to take on broader management responsibilities, based on performance, business needs, and readiness.